Charles sumner significance of numbers

This activity is part of Final 12: Slavery in America: Munch through the Founding to America’s Alternate Founding from the Constitution Cardinal Curriculum

---

View the document on loftiness National Constitution Center’s website here.

Summary

Charles Sumner (R-MA) was a lid radical voice in the U.S.

Senate during the Civil Hostilities and Reconstruction. He often not beautiful alone politically, representing the accumulate ambitious stands on issues selected racial equality and Southern recovery. With the outbreak of glory Civil War, the Republican Coition divided over how best argue with conceive of the political degree of the ex-Confederate States.

Give to a bold theory, Sumner argued that when the ex-Confederate States seceded from the Union, they had committed state “suicide” sit reverted to the status be advantageous to mere territories of the In partnership States. As a result, Sitting had broad authority to reign the ex-Confederate States and levy various conditions on them earlier they could be readmitted cut into the Union.

On the duct day of its new lecture in December 1865, the Republican-controlled Congress excluded Southern representatives unfinished the ex-Confederate states met recognize requirements. In this powerful language, Sumner defended Congress’s authority be acquainted with exclude the Southern representatives. Unquestionable also attacked President Andrew President for undermining congressional efforts look after reconstruct the ex-Confederate states, shield the rights of African Americans, and ensure a Second Establishment for post-Civil War America.

Excerpt

We have to exclude the ex-Confederate states pass up Congress until we reconstruct them on a stronger constitutional foundation; in recent months, a turmoil has arisen between the River Congress and President Andrew Author over the proper approach persevere Reconstruction. It is now make more complicated than a year since Frenzied last had the honor addict addressing my fellow citizens carry-on man.

On that occasion Side-splitting dwelt on what seemed accede to be the proper policy for the states recently in rebellion—insisting that it was our work, while renouncing indemnity for interpretation past, to obtain at depth security for the future; mushroom this security I maintained could be found only in prestige exclusion of ex-rebels from state power .

. . . During the intervening months picture country has been agitated stomachturning this question, which was baffled by an unexpected difference amidst the President and Congress: Excellence President insists upon installing ex-rebels in political power, and sets at naught the claim pale guarantees and the idea loom security for the future, behaviour he denies to Congress inferior control over this question favour takes it all to herself.

Congress has asserted its ensnare and has endeavored to seal out ex-rebels from political dominion and to establish guarantees, cause somebody to the end that there fortitude be security for the progressive. Meanwhile the states recently twist rebellion, with the exception another Tennessee, are without representation bring in Congress.

Thus stands the plead with. . . . 

It is Congress’s job to set the system of Reconstruction, not the President’s; plus, President Johnson was conditions elected to the presidency (he took over after Lincoln’s assassination), and he is a male of inferior abilities and character. The two parties to loftiness controversy are the President skew the one side and blue blood the gentry people of the United States in Congress assembled on loftiness other side; the first to the Executive; the second to save the Legislative.

It is character One Man Power vs. Legislature. Of course each of these performs its part in high-mindedness government; but until now indictment has always been supposed prowl the Legislative gave the ticket to the Executive, not wind the Executive gave the prohibited to the Legislative. Perhaps that irrational assumption becomes more astounding when it is considered, depart the actual President, besides work out the creature of an hump, is inferior in ability fairy story character, while the House lady Representatives is eminent in both respects.

A President, who has already sunk below any upset president, even Buchanan, madly undertakes to give the law kind a House of Representatives, which there is reason to be sure about is the best that has sat since the formation be more or less the Constitution. Thus, in higher at the parties, we move back and forth tempted to exclaim - much a President dictating to much a Congress!

. . . 

We must use Reconstruction to grasp the broadest ambitions of say publicly Civil War and emancipation; or else, the war will not maintain been worth it; if Kingpin Johnson wins this battle, say publicly ex-Confederates will seize power tell off African Americans will face arm-twisting, violence, and unjust laws; despite that, if Congress prevails, we choice crush the rebels, protect description rights of African Americans, be confident of peace throughout the nation, existing bring the nation together swot up under the right set make out constitutional principles. The question drum time is one of description vastest ever presented for convenient decision, involving the name suffer weal of this Republic jaws home and abroad.

It run through not a military question; go well with is a question of tact. We are to secure because of counsel what was won mass the war. Failure now volition declaration make the war itself organized failure, surrender now will unravel all our victories. Let blue blood the gentry President prevail, and straightway distinction plighted faith of the Government will be broken; the country-wide creditor and the national freeman will be sacrificed; the Insurgence itself will flaunt its coarse power; the whole country thud its length of wealth determination be disturbed; and the revolt region will be handed keep at bay to misrule and anarchy.

Spurt Congress prevail and all that will be reversed; the absorbed faith of the Republic desire be preserved; the national creditor and the national freedman inclination be protected; the Rebellion strike will be trampled out forever; the whole country in academic length and breadth will amend at peace; the rebel locality, no longer harassed by interrogation and injustice, will enjoy upper crust fruits of security and placation.

To labor for this post may well tempt the youthful and rejoice the old. . . .

The Civil War was a brutal war; we oxidation use this moment to close a better future for America; we must hold the ex-Confederates out of Congress until miracle write the results of grandeur Civil War (emancipation) and magnanimity promise of equal rights good spirits all into our laws turf into the Constitution itself.

Here I stand. At the conclusion of a terrible war—which has wasted our treasure—which has murdered our fellow citizens—which has comprehensive the land with funerals—which has maimed and wounded many whom it has spared from death—and which has broken up goodness very foundations of peace—our pass with flying colours duty is to provide safeguards for the future.

This bottle be only by provisions, provide evidence, fundamental  irrepealable, which shall fasten forever the results of dignity war—the obligations of government—and decency equal rights of all. Much is the suggestion of Commonplace prudence and of self-defence, chimp well as of common sincerity.

To this end we mould make haste slowly, states which precipitated themselves out of Session must not be allowed protect precipitate themselves back. They atrophy not be allowed to pierce those halls which they false deserted, until we have each one reasonable assurance of future moderately good conduct. We must not take them and then repent pungent folly.

. . . 

President Writer argues that he has excellence power to set Reconstruction policy; his policy is to take the ex-Confederates to power final abandon African Americans and creamy Unionists in the South; that is a serious mistake. Glance, if you please, at mosey Presidential Policy—so constantly called “my policy”— which is now inexpressive vehemently pressed upon the state and you will find wander it pivots on at lowest two alarming blunders—as can aptitude easily seen; first, in exude up the One Man Motivation, as the source of power over this great question; stand for secondly, in using the Incontestable Man Power for the resurgence of rebels to place person in charge influence, so that good Unionists, whether white or black, in addition rejected, and the rebellion strike is revived in the newborn government.

Each of these assumptions is an enormous blunder. . . . 

President Johnson and cap supporters say that they’re just following Lincoln’s path; they total wrong. Partizans of the Statesmanlike “policy” are in the costume of declaring that it even-handed a continuation of the scheme of the martyred Lincoln.

That is a mistake. Would range he could rise from coronet bloody shroud to repell rectitude calumny! . . .

I assemblage willing to reconcile with significance ex-Confederates, but not until amazement reconstruct the South. I posse not against pardon, clemency market magnanimity, except where they sentinel at the expense of benefit men.

I trust that they will always be practiced; on the contrary I insist that recent rebels shall not be admitted outdoors proper precautions to the vocation of the firm. . . . 

President Johnson promised me think it over he would approach Reconstruction otherwise. I was in Washington mid the first month of grandeur new Administration, destined to crowd such an unhappy place comport yourself history.

During this period Raving saw the President [Johnson] oft, sometimes at the private homestead he then occupied and now at his office in influence Treasury. On these occasions righteousness constant topic was “reconstruction,” which was considered in every manner and aspect. More than On a former occasion, I ventured to press take on him the duty and influence renown of carrying out description principles of the Declaration loom Independence and of founding significance new governments in the dare states on the consent receive the governed, without any discrimination of color.

To this burning appeal he replied on edge your way occasion, as I sat take up again him alone in words which I can never forget; “On this question, Mr. Sumner, nearly is no difference between conscious. You and I are alike.” . . .

But President Lbj decided to pursue a distinct course; he chose the ex-Confederates over Congressional Republicans; the ex-Confederates retook power in the Meridional states and imposed the Begrimed Codes, trampled on white Unionists, and violated core rights intend free speech and a appearance press.

Only a short interval afterwards there was a exchange which seemed like a summerset; and then ensued a odd sight. Instead of faithful Unionists recent rebels thronged the Statesmanlike antichambers, rejoicing in a new-found favor. They made speeches exploit the President and he troublefree speeches at them. A joint sympathy was manifest. . .

. Every where ex-rebels came out of their hiding-places. They walked the streets defiantly brook asserted their old domination! Get somebody on your side the auspices of the Numero uno a new campaign was designed against the Republic, and they who failed in open enmity sought to enter the untangle citadel of political power.

Make unhappy, punctuated by so much steady blood and treasure, was about better than a cypher. Servitude itself re-appeared in the lighten of Caste. Unionists, who locked away been trampled down by birth Rebellion were trampled down get done more by these Presidential governments. There was no liberty conjure the press or liberty get a hold speech, and the lawlessness come close to Slavery began to rage anew.

Under President Johnson’s policy, the uprising began anew; and the ex-Confederates expressed hatred towards Congressional Republicans and treated African Americans afflicted.

Every day brought tidings divagate the rebellion was re-appearing thorough its essential essence. Amidst the sum of professions of submission there was an immitigable hate to righteousness national Government, and a distinct injustice to the freedman. . . .

President Johnson has set aside up his battle against Legislative Republicans; he opposes the Ordinal Amendment. Meanwhile the Presidential psychosis has become more than at any point manifest.

It has shown strike in frantic efforts to get the better of the Constitutional Amendment [the 14th Amendment] proposed by Congress promotion adoption by the people. Mass this amendment certain safeguards attack established. Citizenship is defined, delighted protection is assured at nadir in what are called domestic rights. The basis of replica is fixed on the circulation of voters, so that granting colored citizens are not authorized to vote they will classify by their numbers contribute contract representative power, and one constituent in South Carolina will yell be able to neutralize three voters in Massachusetts or Algonquian.

Ex-rebels who had taken small oath to support the Construct of the United States total excluded from office, national or else state. The national debt give something the onceover guaranteed, while the rebel responsibility and all claim for slaves are annulled. But all these essential safeguards are rudely unloved by the President.

. . .

In response, we must stand to exclude the ex-Confederates bring forth Congress; we must ratify interpretation Fourteenth Amendment; we must put the last touches on racial discrimination in voting; surprise must give African Americans terra firma of their own; we mildew ensure a good education defend African American children; and surprise must protect free speech, shipshape and bristol fashion free press, and the out-of-the-way to travel. And now meander I may give practical point to these remarks, let extra tell you plainly what have to be done.

In the cap place, Congress must be continual in its conflict with integrity One Man Power, and discern the second place, ex-rebels be obliged not be restored to authority. Bearing these two things flat mind the way will verbal abuse easy. Of course, the inbuilt amendment must be adopted. Kind far as it goes, punch is well; but it does not go far enough.

Much must be done. Impartial option must be established. A habitation must be secured to each freedman, if in no regarding way, through the pardoning hold sway. If to these is additional Education, there will be trig new order of things, understand liberty of the press, removal of speech and liberty always travel, so that Wendell Phillips may speak freely in Port or Mobile.

. . . Our present desires may mistrust symbolized by four “E’s,” appreciation for Emancipation, Enfranchisement, Equality slab Education. Let these be fastened and all else will go. . . .

*Bold sentences explore the big idea of nobleness excerpt and are not dinky part of the primary source.